In the episode "Evicted!," the frog is a disguise worn by the tiger. At first, it looks like a regular frog, but then a tiger jumps out of it, revealing it is a costume. It threw potions for food and fire as soon Finn and Jake ran away.
When it's a frog, it's wrinkly and a teal-like color that has lime green eyes.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.